4 Comments
User's avatar
bruce goodman's avatar

Don’t know why my comment posted before I finished. The need for a duplicate backup continuously reliable system capable of providing peak power for weeks at a time makes wind and solar uncompetitive. Battery backup at grid scale is not close to affordable or practical.

Data centers developers are well aware of the energy and water issues and could not obtain financing if they do not have persuasive answers for them.

bruce goodman's avatar

Good article but it does not mention that data centers are increasingly using air cooled or closed loop water cooling systems with waste water as the input. These systems may use more electricity than evaporative water cooling systems, but there is a great deal of innovation and discovery in industry’s efforts to minimize water and electricity impacts of data centers.

The point about moratoriums forcing data centers into dirty grids is trivial. While hydropower and nuclear are the cleanest electricity generators,, wind and solar are neither cleaner nor cheaper than fossil fuel plants when one considers the entire life cycle and

STEVE SELINGER's avatar

Great article. But I would not accept the narrative that "emissions" of co2 are a negative. Greenhouses have about 1300-1500 ppm of co2 while our atmosphere has only about 420 ppm of co2. This has lead to the greening of the Earth--even per NASA.

The more co2 the better!

David Moran's avatar

Well done. The Crimson editors should resign; but of course they won’t even reply.